Interactive webcast player
Licensing Sub-Committee (Licensing Act 2003 Matters)
Thursday, 12th November 2026 at 2:00pm
Speaking:
Start of webcast
Share this agenda point
1 Introductions
Share this agenda point
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 3
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 9
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 23
-
Seat 25
-
Seat 26
-
Seat 1
4 Declarations of Interest
Share this agenda point
6 Application for new Premises Licence - Dubs In The Middle.
Share this agenda point
-
Seat 25
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 25
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 28
-
Seat 9
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 28
-
Seat 9
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 3
-
Seat 3
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 3
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 3
-
Seat 28
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 28
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 29
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 29
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 29
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 29
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 29
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 3
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 8
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 28
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 28
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 28
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 22
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 28
8 Decision
Share this agenda point
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 1
-
Seat 9
-
Seat 1
-
Webcast Finished
Disclaimer: This transcript was automatically generated, so it may contain errors. Please view the webcast to confirm whether the content is accurate.
1 Introductions
Seat 1 - 0:00:02
I'll bang my gavel.Hello, and welcome to this meeting of Cotswold District Council Licencing Committee.
We're here to discuss the application for one new premises licence, stops in the middle.
So my name is Delice Neel, and I am currently chair of the Panning and Licencing Committee,
so I will chair this meeting.
I would like to introduce my colleagues.
Seat 3 - 0:00:28
Seat 8 - 0:00:34
Michael van I'm Councillor for Fairford North and Councillor Paul Evans I haveSeat 1 - 0:00:40
the privilege of representing the beaches ward in Sire ancestor so thethree of us are members of the planning and licencing committee so we've done
the appropriate training to conduct this licencing hearing and I'd like now to
ask the officers to introduce themselves
Thank you.
Thank you.
Seat 9 - 0:00:55
Mari Barnes, legal advisor to this committee.Seat 22 - 0:00:58
April Paintain, senior officer for noise and amenities in part of the environmental healthteam.
Seat 23 - 0:01:11
Marianne Garrett, senior officer in noise and amenities, same as April, for the environmentalprotection team.
Seat 25 - 0:01:16
Emma Sparks, Licencing Officer for Cotswold District Council.Seat 26 - 0:01:22
Julia Gibson, Democratic Services Officer.4 Declarations of Interest
Seat 1 - 0:01:27
Thank you very much. Do we have any apologies for absence? And any substitutions? Wonderful.Any declarations of interest?
6 Application for new Premises Licence - Dubs In The Middle.
So this is an application for a new premises licence.
So I'm going to run through the conditions,
rather the four licencing objectives,
which are the prevention of crime and disorder,
public safety, the prevention of public nuisance,
and the protection of children from harm.
So when we're considering the application,
we will be looking at the four licencing objectives
and carrying out this committee in accordance
with our licencing policy at Cotswold District Council.
So we will hear from various people.
So we'll be hearing from the licencing officer first of all.
And then we as a committee will have opportunities
to ask questions of the licencing officer.
Then we'll hear from the applicant.
and we'll have opportunities to ask questions of the applicant.
Then we can hear any other people who wish to make a representation and ask questions
of them.
So there is a sort of ability for people to cross -question each other so that we are all
fully cognisant of what's going on.
At the end of these discussions, the three of us will retire with our legal officer to
consider the merits of the application and we can make various different
recommendations. So we can grant the application as requested, grant the
application subject to conditions such as that are necessary to promote the
licencing objectives or refuse the application in whole or in part where
it's necessary in order to promote the licencing objectives. So that's the
things that we'll be discussing when we meet in private to consider the
application. Is everybody clear on all that? Good. Right so I am now going to ask our licencing
Seat 25 - 0:03:41
officers to outline the application. Thank you very much. Thank you chair. Good afternooneveryone. This is an application for premises licence for dubs in the middle located on
the Tottenham Manor Farm Estate, Tottenham Road, Moreton and Marsh. The
activities applied for can be viewed within the report in at section 1 .2. The
applicant has applied for two events per annum. These would be held within May
2027 and August 2027 each limited to Wednesday to Monday. The police and the
Representations in support can be found in Annex D.
Representations in objection have been received from the technical pollution team who are in attendance
and from a member of the public who is not in attendance this afternoon.
Their objections can be found in the supplement.
The Cotswold District Council Statement of Licencing Policy 2021 is to be reviewed and updated every five years.
This is currently in progress and until publication the current policy remains in place to guide
the process.
The licencing authority will only apply terms and conditions to licences to promote one
or more of the licencing objectives and ensure that they are relevant to the individual circumstances
of the application.
They include prevention and crime and disorder, public safety, prevention of public nuisance,
licence, protection of children from harm. The licencing authority will always seek to
ensure that conditions are necessary, proportionate and reasonable and will avoid the use of conditions
which duplicate other legal requirements that apply to an employer or operator of the premises.
The licencing authority will consider every application on its individual merits, will
seek to balance the needs of the local community and commercial premises and activities against
those who may be concerned with the adverse impacts for licenced premises.
The options for consideration by the subcommittee are to grant the application as requested,
to grant the application subject to conditions that are necessary to promote the licencing
objectives, refuse the application in whole or in part where it is necessary to promote
the licencing objectives.
Thank you, Chair.
I have nothing further to add.
Seat 1 - 0:06:19
Thank you very much. Members, do you have any questions to ask the licencing officer?I did ask you this before, but just for clarification, the licence is granted to the applicant, it's
granted to the people who own Todd and Amanda farm is that correct that's
correct yes yeah okay okay we may come up with some more questions later on but
Seat 25 - 0:07:00
would you would you like to introduce the applicant for us thank you theapplicant today is Natalie Natalie Ellott and she is being represented by
Seat 1 - 0:07:10
Rebecca Lowe. Hello Rebecca are you? I am yes. Okay so would you like to presentSeat 28 - 0:07:20
the application to us? Thank you very much. Thank you very much for theopportunity chair and good afternoon councillors and I will try not to take
up too much of your time this afternoon and as you've heard from from Emma I
appear here with Natalie who is the applicant for this licence and who is
the founder, owner and operator of Dubs in the Middle.
The festival, the event, it really is her baby, Councillors.
She's described it to me in those terms.
She's really passionate about it.
She's really quite emotional about these proceedings today.
So I'd ask you to give her a little bit of leeway
in that regard, if she's a bit nervous
answering any questions that you might have.
I have told her that you're not scary.
I have reassured her of that, but this means a lot to her
and she's quite nervous.
So I'll just start by saying that if that's OK.
I think you've been advised as well that Natalie does
have a hearing impairment, so she might just
need you to repeat questions or speak fairly clearly for her
if you have any questions for her at the conclusion
of my submissions.
So that's sort of the housekeeping, if you like.
On to sort of more substantive matters.
I'll be quite candid at the outset, councillors.
It's a bit of an odd application, this one,
because there's quite a number of sort of moving parts
within this application and sort of a few hypotheticals,
if you like.
So I'll explain what I mean by that shortly
and sort of talk you through how I think we might navigate
through those.
But in the first instance, I'll just
give you a little bit of background to Natalie,
to what DUBBS in the middle is, to what the event is proposed
to be, just to add a little bit of colour to this
and a little bit of detail to what the event would
be if you did decide to grant this licence today.
So Natalie's got a background herself in the events industry, in the hospitality industry,
in the festival industry.
Sort of professionally she works within waste management at multiple festivals with a particular
emphasis on sort of sustainability, renewability within sort of festival events.
But Dubs, as I've said, is sort of her passion project.
She's described it to me as a genuinely community focused event.
There are attendees to this event that return year on year on year.
She knows a lot of the people who come by name.
She knows their storeys.
She knows their families.
She knows what they need for their kids to be able to attend.
Some of her attendees need adjustments.
It's a really personal affair.
She describes it as sort of a family -friendly gathering of like -minded individuals.
It is a festival, but it isn't one that's focused on music activity.
Music activity is a part of it.
It's a large part of it and that is largely why we're here today.
But it's not one that's sort of focused around music.
It's designed for and it's aimed at VW, Volkswagen owners
and what Natalie describes as van lifers.
So it does of course involve music as I've said,
but there are a number of other activities going on around the site
and a number of other focuses.
So we've got trade stalls, we've got kids entertainment,
we've got a dog show, we've got a fun fair,
We've got van displays, vehicle displays.
So it's a bit of an eclectic mix of activities going on at this event.
As I've said, it's genuinely family friendly,
so a lot of attendees bringing their children along to this event with them.
A lot of attendees bringing their pets along with them.
There's a lot of dogs that come to the festival.
The demographic of sort of ticket purchasers,
Natalie tells me, is usually between 30 and 60 years of age.
So it's not a festival that's focused at young people.
it's families and older people that attend this.
High attendance from ex -forces, from veterans,
who come along sort of associated
with the van focus of the event.
So as I'm sure you can imagine, this in itself
sort of sets the tone for the event
and the type of activities that are operated within it.
It's one that is much less intense than you
might expect for sort of a standard music festival event.
It's somewhere where families are comfortable bringing
their children, where people are comfortable bringing their dogs, etc.
Natalie's explained to me, for example, that there's absolutely no pyrotechnics or any
fireworks effects, anything like that that go on at the event because they're cognizant
of the sorts of people that attend, the vulnerability of dogs, the veteran community who don't enjoy
that sort of noise production, etc.
So that all feeds into this being sort of a slightly less intensive, noisy event that
you might think of as a music festival.
Dobbs has been carried out for over 10 years at other locations across the country.
So 2014 through to 2024, the event was held at Ashdown Farm in Evesham,
although obviously no events took place in 2020 or 2021.
So that 10 years span with a gap of two years at Ashdown Farm.
It left this location, not only moved from this location,
only because it actually became too small as a location for the event as it's grown in popularity.
and you'll see from your papers that we're seeking a licence here for up to 4999, so up to 5 ,000
effectively for this event. 2025, the event was held at Hanley Castle in Worcestershire and this
year, so May 26th at Brookfield Farm again in Evesham. At all of those locations Natalie has
an excellent track record. Environmental health teams who she's worked with at these other
locations have always been really pleased with the way that she's operated. They've carried out
noise monitoring during the events, there have never been any issues flagged by them.
Now, I appreciate, you appreciate, councillors, that location is of course paramount in licencing
applications. And as I'm sure April will highlight to you, a lack of issue in one location doesn't
necessarily translate to the exact same outcome in another. However, Natalie hasn't carried
out these events in a vacuum, she hasn't carried them out in hugely urban locations, or alternatively
in hugely remote locations with no, you know,
prospect of impacting on nearby noise -sensitive users.
She's operated these events very close to noise -sensitive users
previously, including, for example,
being 400 metres away from a school carrying out GCSE exams
at the time with no adverse impact.
This year, to give you an example, at Brookfield Farm,
the nearest noise -sensitive receptor was a house less
than 200 metres away.
A race course 230 metres away with stables, no complaints whatsoever from those.
And an occupied caravan park less than 850 metres away.
Now I mention that specifically because this was the location where the environmental health
team for this event carried out sound recordings, noise recordings, monitoring during the event.
And Natalie sort of gone back to the environmental health officer there to ask them what levels
they were recording there and they were talking about around 43 .5 decibels at that location.
At the school I mentioned in 2025, the same readings were around 44 decibel level, 400
metres away from where the music was taking place.
So as I say, this isn't evidence of what the decibel levels will be at this location, absolutely,
But I would say that this is still important,
probative evidence in terms of Natalie's ability to operate
a well -run event that doesn't cause issues for those
in the vicinity.
It's not a noisy event that results in lots
of noise complaints.
As I say, whilst evidence of good operation elsewhere
is not conclusive evidence that there wouldn't be issues
at another location, I have no doubt that if there were
evidence of problems elsewhere, officers would adduce those as evidence that there might
be problems here. So this isn't conclusive, councillors, but I would suggest it's important
evidence for you to consider when making your decision.
What it is is evidence that this style of event is not such that the noise carries great
distance or causes nuisance to those in the vicinity, and it's our submission that Natalie
would be able to achieve that in this location also.
Now for the event scheduled to take place in 2027 and then beyond because this application has been sought for an event or two events initially and I'll touch on that shortly, per year going forward.
The event had been scheduled in 2027 to operate in Wick near Pershaw but unfortunately the landowner there had reneged on the agreement for Natalie to use the land which has put her in a tricky position.
So she approached Alistair. Alistair is a gentleman who owns and operates
Todenham Farm about the possibility of carrying out the event at the premises
that is the subject of this hearing today. Natalie sees that location as the
perfect location for this event for a number of reasons. She says the layout
works well for an event with relatively few noise -sensitive receptors nearby.
It's well placed in terms of the flat terrain of the area itself, the camper vans etc.
And Natalie has, as I've said, a lot of ex -vectrine campers who need sort of an accessible location.
The fields are close but are segregated in good quantity for camping space.
And also just sort of personally, Natalie has a connexion to this area.
She's born and brought up in the Cotswolds.
She's worked in Moreton in Marsh in the local charity shop.
So she knows a lot of locals and a lot of the locals here actually attend the event on a regular basis
The site also has all the infrastructure needed in terms of water roadways etc
Etc and Natalie wants to work with the farm itself and with their catering business for the event
So giving a boost to this local business if the event were to proceed
And you might well be familiar with the location counsellors
I don't know but just for completeness, Todnamanna Farm is a 900 acre family run farm which sits
at the heart of the Cotswolds. It comprises farm shop, restaurant, accommodation, butchery
school and then a significant amount of land. That land has often been used for large scale
events. In fact as we speak it is being used for the Cotswold Christmas Fair which attracts
more than 6000 visitors annually, hence the sort of existing infrastructure that I mentioned
with this location. So it's this piece of land that's proposed to be used. It's
off Toddenham Road. It is very close to a mixed industrial estate which sits
between the site and the nearest residents and very very near bordering
almost the the fire service training college as well. So this is a rural space
but it's not one that is sort of a solely residential locality. There are of
course residents nearby but there is also commercial and other noise
producing use in the immediate vicinity.
So the application lodged, as you've heard from Emma,
sought permission for certain items
that my client no longer requests from you.
So I'll just outline the position
as we are today in this regard.
So firstly, as you heard from Emma,
the application initially sought permission
for two events per calendar year.
My client no longer seeks such permission
by way of this application.
Instead, she asks you to grant permission
for one event per calendar year.
Secondly, the application initially sought permission for regulated entertainment to
take place Thursday through to Monday.
My client no longer seeks permission for Mondays in regards to this application.
She seeks licenceable activities from Wednesday through to Sunday only, but with no regulated
entertainment on the Wednesday.
So the Wednesday she would be seeking sale of alcohol only and just by way of additional
information the Wednesday at these events is for crew and traders only so it would be sale of
alcohol but for a smaller section on the Wednesday. So she seeks regulated entertainment as you'll
have seen from the papers each day now Thursday to Sunday from nine o 'clock in the morning until
11 o 'clock at night with a silent disco then to take place afterwards through to the terminal hour.
Natalie proposed various conditions be added to the licence as part of our application and she entered into dialogue during the consultation period with the police who suggested streamlining those to an extent.
So those streamlined conditions are on page 39 of your main agenda papers.
So where we are now, where we are today, is that we're asking you to grant a licence for the hours applied for Wednesday to Sunday, but not the Monday.
And we're asking you to grant on the basis of the conditions at page 39.
But with one amendment, which I've just touched on as follows, so that it would say the premises licence permits one event, the festival, to take place each calendar year.
The event will operate Wednesday to Monday, but with no licenseable activities on the Monday and will have a maximum capacity of 4999 persons.
By way of additional information as well, councillors, this event would always take place in May.
That would be when she would propose it to happen.
And it only works in that month because of the calendar of other Volkswagen events.
Something I wasn't aware of, but that Natalie has educated me on throughout this process.
So it would always be the Whitsun Bank holiday in May that it would take place.
So, as you'll be aware, Councillors, there are two representations in respect of this application.
I have, and Natalie has, communicated those amendments to April prior to today's hearing and to the residential objector.
So, i .e. the fact that it's one event we're seeking and it's four days of regulated entertainment that we're seeking.
But as you'll, of course, be aware,
those representations are maintained.
So it's only right that I spend a little bit of time
exploring those now.
I'll start then with the Environmental Health
Team's representation.
I hope April will agree that it's fair for me to say that
there are effectively two strands to the representation,
two grounds upon which the objection is made today.
Sorry, did you have a question?
I'll ask you to pause a minute.
Of course.
Seat 9 - 0:21:52
Oh, sorry.Sorry.
I've just raised, and we probably
didn't say at the beginning, we are actually
meant to have 15 minutes each for every party.
And I believe that you're very close to the 15 minutes.
I've got quite some way to go.
I mean, Chair, it's up to you.
But we are meant to obviously provide equal time
to every party that wishes to speak.
I'm so sorry.
We should have made that clear at the beginning.
and it's not clear in the format of the protocol.
So, can you manage an extra five minutes?
Would that be enough?
How much time do you think you need?
So, I can't leave 15, have I?
We're at 20 minutes in, and I don't think the introduction
took very long.
I can cheque the exact time.
Seat 1 - 0:22:40
Shall I give you until half past?Do you think that would be okay?
Are you happy with that, colleagues?
Very much so, yes.
Yeah, we'll give you till half past because we didn't I apologise that we didn't
Tell you that the time was were you informed beforehand that the time was limited
I wasn't it may well have been in the papers, but I know I don't think I was now
I've appeared before and I don't recall there being a time limit. So that may be my fault
I wasn't aware that there was a time limit, but my legal representative tells me that that is
Apologies it is in the in our licencing policy on
procedure online and just and it does say at number F in our papers each
party's allowed a maximum period of 15 minutes to make their relevant
statements unless the chairman expressly approves otherwise. I expressly approve
that you can go on to the half past okay. Okay all right I'll do my best in the next
Seat 28 - 0:23:37
yeah I'll do my best in the next seven minutes to speak slightly quicker inthat case. All right thank you very much chair appreciate it. So there are two
strands I think to April's representation. First one being what is
colloquially referred to as the POP code, properly referred to as the code of
practise on environmental noise control at concerts. So I'll stick with the POP
code for speed if I may. So the first strand effectively states that to
summarise another proposed event is already taking place at this location.
Arc Tangent which is a heavy metal festival that's been granted a licence
for this space. And the first strand of the representation is that that will
take up this site's full allocation of concert days per year per venue. We would
dispute the position that a licence cannot be granted if the proposed event
is not absolutely and strictly in accordance with the POP Code for a
number of reasons. Firstly the POP Code is just that it's a code of practise. It
is a guidance document which was designed to provide advice and
assistance to people and bodies with regards to how large music events should
It does not and never did have any legal or statutory footing.
It is a guide and therefore there is nothing to suggest that you can't grant a licence even if you consider that the proposed event might be outside of the parameters of the Code.
There are hundreds of examples up and down the country of event venues which do operate out with the Code.
By way of brief, and I was going to be less brief, but by way of brief example, Lancashire County Cricket Cub in my neck of the woods.
eight days at 80 decibels is what they're permitted under their licence.
Numerous other locations across the country, Heaton Park, Manchester, closer
to here, Evesham Meadows, Ragley Hall, Cheltenham Racecourse, Fish Meadows,
Knebworth for example where there'll be multiple events throughout a calendar
year. So it isn't a document that provides anything other than guidance,
it's entirely routine for venues to operate otherwise and in accordance with
the code. It is also a document Councillors, it's almost as old as I am,
having been introduced in 1995, some 31 years ago.
A lot has changed since 1995.
It is right to say that no updated or more recent code
has been published, which may be relied upon instead,
but the code was actually withdrawn
by the Chartered Institute of Environmental Health in 2018.
So I would suggest we need to be relatively cautious
about basing licencing decisions on it.
That is particularly true,
given that your licencing policy has a specific section
regarding large -scale outdoor events,
which states that applicants are expected to have had reference
to the event safety guide, the purple guide,
which is a separate guidance document,
your policy makes no reference to the POP code.
So it isn't your policy that this code is used
to guide your licencing decisions.
It's also true given that the Licencing Act
was passed subsequent to the code
and did not incorporate any elements of the code within it.
It is notable that the Code refers to disturbance rather than nuisance, which is a lower threshold than what the Licencing Act requires.
So there's no presumption here that the Prevention of Public Nuisance objective can only be upheld by adherence to the POP Code.
There might be many ways in which this can be achieved.
What you need to be assured of, Councillors, in order to grant this licence, is that this application on its merits will not cause a public nuisance.
Now this is where I'm sort of getting into there being some moving parts
councillors. I am slightly concerned that I'm not going to cover everything I need
to say by half past chair. Could I ask for a little longer? There are a lot of
issues here. I'm totally happy for Environmental Health to have parity with
me on the time that I've spent but I am concerned I'm not going to get to it all.
I don't think you can go on for another 10 minutes let's put it like that. You
don't think I can? No, if you can be as brief as possible that would be great.
Okay, I'll do my best.
So the other element of the representation then is the
concern about this event itself.
So rather than by reference to the POP code, the concern about
the demonstration of how this event will uphold the licencing
objective in terms of prevention of public nuisance.
So environmental health and April in particular, we've had
some conversations over the last few days about the production
of a noise management plan upon which environmental health can
rely in respect to their concerns.
I'll be absolutely candid here.
We find ourselves in an odd position
in that I haven't produced a noise management plan for you
today.
And that is because one had been produced
by an acoustic consultant for my client, which April was
concerned about in terms of its methodology, conclusions,
and the credentials of the consultant who
put it together.
Natalie is really upset about that but she acted on a recommendation.
She takes April's comments on board and she really wants to work with her to try and address her concerns in respect of this event.
So what Natalie has done is to employ a new acoustic consultant with some pretty hefty credentials,
which I won't go into but I can answer questions on if you think appropriate.
He's been instructed though in the last 48 hours, councillors, so he can't produce a plan today.
but he's confident that going forward he will be able to produce something that
will address the concerns that Environmental Health have. So my
suggestion today Councillors is that an additional condition is added to the
licence which reads as follows. A location and event specific acoustic
assessment and noise management plan shall be submitted to Cotswolds
District Council Environmental Health no later than two months before the start
of any event taking place under this licence. These documents must be approved
in writing by environmental health prior to the event being permitted to proceed.
Once approved the noise management plan shall be fully complied with.
Is it possible to get that written so that we can actually look at it or would
that be too complicated? Yes.
Yeah, do you want me to do it?
Yes, I think if we're going to have a condition we need to have it in writing before us so that we can
My apologies Councillors. I was intending obviously to to go into detail with it in submissions
I'm afraid I just wanted to swear that there was going to be a time limit.
I do apologise.
Okay, that's fine. Carry on, we'll give you a few more minutes.
Thank you so much.
Yeah, we feel that you've not been given enough clarity, so we're very happy for you to carry
a little bit but not you know not the half hour. Apologies Councillor, I simply
wasn't aware I recall. I can see that it wasn't made clear to you beforehand so
there we go. Thank you appreciate it. So it's my view Councillors that that
condition provides a solution for all parties. It means that my client doesn't
need to produce the noise management plan today but also that nobody needs to
make any decision without seeing it. April was not content to agree her
representation on the basis of that condition but what I would suggest is
that it protects her position entirely.
Because if a licence is granted
with that condition attached to it,
any event that Natalie proposes
would not be able to proceed
without environmental health specific written approval.
So we're effectively,
it's a bit of a risk on my clients part counsellors,
but we're effectively offering her an absolute veto
on this event if she cannot be convinced
by our new acoustic consultant
that it can take place in a way
that will not cause a nuisance.
This condition also allows for a bit of flex, Councillors, because of the other element of this that has moving parts,
and that is the presence of the other festival event that I've referenced.
Whilst the licence for that festival has been granted, Councillors, the landowner advises me that that operator hasn't actually signed with them on the dotted line in terms of the use and occupation of the space itself.
So as such, it isn't absolutely certain yet that that other licence will even be used.
The presence of that event is a significant factor in environmental health's consideration of this application.
And so this condition would allow for a change in context to be taken into account with a future noise management plan and acoustic assessment to be submitted.
Very briefly, Councillors, there is another representation from a resident which I would have liked to have given more time to, and I appreciate that I can't,
but I'd like it just to put on the record
that I'm not dismissing or ignoring that representation.
I'm just trying to truncate what I'm saying.
But what I would say is that this is one residential objector
in a location where there are a number of residents.
And in fact, what you have before you is one objection
and quite a large amount of support,
which I'd ask you to give your attention to in the papers
when making your decision.
But I would say that I think one reason
that there is support and limited objection from the local community for
this application is because Natalie has engaged with the local community before
submitting the application. You'll see that there is a specific response from
the parish council who Natalie's engaged with. She's engaged with local schools,
local members of the community before proceeding to lodge the application.
There is a concern with regards to traffic in the other
representation. I won't take time giving our response to those but if you have
any questions about traffic we're able to provide responses. In conclusion though
what I would say councillors is that effectively the sole issue before you
today is what noise levels can be achieved in respect of this event,
whether the other event is taking place or not and whether or not they would
cause a nuisance. This application is therefore really in terms of what's
disputed about the carrying of music noise only. We regret that we're not in a
to produce for you a noise management plan that answers all of April's
questions and all of your questions today. It's unfortunate but we are where
we are with that. But we would submit that the addition of the condition that
helpfully you're being provided with I think now, would ensure that this event
cannot proceed unless your environmental health team is satisfied that it can go
forward without causing a nuisance. There are no crime and disorder, public safety,
protection of children reasons referred to in the representations. The only
concern therefore is the prevention of public nuisance and this condition
provides reassurance I would submit through effectively an absolute veto. If
your team aren't happy with the specifics the event absolutely so if
your team aren't happy with this the event won't proceed so I would suggest
it's proportionate to grant on that basis because you can be assured that
one way or another the licencing objectives will be upheld. There's a couple of documents
that I'd like to just gently point you towards and I'll perhaps do that in my summing up
if that's all right. Thank you for your patience and your indulgence. I do apologise.
Thank you very much. I'm sorry about the confusion.
That's okay?
I'll just switch to you on the mic.
Okay.
Seat 9 - 0:35:13
Sorry, can I just put into the record that we've just been passed the condition thatyou suggested, just so that we're clear on what's just been passed to us. Thank you.
Seat 1 - 0:35:29
Seat 1 - 0:35:42
Thank you.Seat 3 - 0:35:52
I am hunting for the comments of the parish Council.Where am I going to find them?
Seat 3 - 0:36:30
I hadn't appreciated that although I drove for quite a little way out of Morton -in -the -Marshto reach Tottenham, which looked to me as a separate village, that it was all part of
Seat 1 - 0:36:57
Seat 1 - 0:36:58
Seat 3 - 0:36:59
Morton and the marsh so I had seen it before the answer the answer is I'm Iam sorry following on from what you've just said I do want to have a separate
discussion about the addendum that we've received and the timing of that separate
discussion is something which I'd like to consider at this stage.
Seat 1 - 0:37:30
Seat 1 - 0:37:32
Seat 1 - 0:37:34
Seat 1 - 0:37:36
Yes. I don't want to go see it.Seat 1 - 0:37:38
Oh, thank you very much. Sorry. Thank you so much. Yes, we'll wait for the noise officer's report and then you can raise that with her. Thank you, Councillor Fan. Any other questions?Seat 3 - 0:37:51
I've got a puzzle on the noise report which is these festivals have been going for a number of yearsand as to how it is that only now after a number of years that there's been a report which isn't
satisfactory for the reasons given by the council officer?
Seat 28 - 0:38:20
Yeah, I can help with that.So this would be the first year that this event has
taken place at this location.
So there will have been noise management plans produced
for this event at the other localities
where it's taken place over the years,
but they need to be specific to the location
because they need to obviously deal
with where the nearest noise sensitive receptors are
to that particular locality.
In terms of the production of a management plan for this event,
Natalie had submitted suggested conditions to be added to the licence
with regards to this application. If the licence were granted, she'd suggested X
number of conditions would be added. One of those conditions would be the
putting together of and approval of by the Safety Advisory Group an event
management plan. So that would include noise management, noise management
elements of it and the noise management plan within the event management plan.
Now it's quite common in my experience, Councillors, for licences for festivals and large events
to take that format so that a condition will say there must be an event management plan
or there must be a noise management plan. But for that actual plan, the detail of that
plan to be produced nearer the time of the event, because various conversations will
need to be had with authorities, through the safety advisory group, et cetera, et cetera.
In this circumstance, I think Natalie had discussed with officers the production of an example event management plan for the event with the licence application.
And she was advised that anything she submits with the application would become public record as part of the application and potentially these proceedings.
And Natalie's concern was her event management plan includes safeguarding details, emergency evacuation details, etc.
Things that it would not be sensible to put in the public domain.
So as I say, it's entirely usually my experience for a licence to be granted which requires other documents to be produced at a later date.
That's exactly how Natalie approached her application.
The proposed condition here specifically requires a noise management plan that deals with all of the issues that April has raised to environmental health satisfaction before the event proceeds.
Now I wouldn't normally propose a condition like this because I'd like to come before you with a noise management plan
That's ready for you to look at but we are where we are the circumstances are that April had instructed somebody to produce such a pack
April I'm sorry Natalie had instructed somebody to produce such a plan
It didn't come up to standard April highlighted that she wasn't happy with it
So Natalie has instructed somebody else to produce one and we just are where we are in terms of timings
that I can't produce it to you today. I'll be candid, Councillor, I'd like to
have been able to but we just aren't there on time so that's why I'm
suggesting this condition. The alternative for my client is that we
have to go through this application process all over again but she's already
here, we've already come this far and my suggestion is that this condition
ensures that a noise management plan will be produced that's to environmental
health satisfaction before the event proceeding should you decide to grant
the licence. Thank you very much. Natalie just asked me to mention that the
qualifications of the the new acoustic consultant as I said I think in my
submission is pretty robust and we can talk about him if you if you'd like some
Seat 1 - 0:41:33
details. No that's fine thank you very much. Did you have anything else youwanted to ask? Councillor Evans has got the questions. I had a whole load of
Seat 8 - 0:41:43
questions actually during before reading the application and you managedto answer most of them so thank you. Thank you very much yes. There's two outstanding.
How many vehicles would you reasonably expect? Yeah so there was reference I think in one
of the representations wasn't there to 10 ,000 vehicle movements and that absolutely isn't
the case. So it's at 5 ,000 capacity events but a lot of people come together, families
come together, groups come together. So Natalie have you got an idea in terms of number of
vehicles in total.
We only allow a maximum, and that's if we sell out, of 1 ,200
vehicles to camp.
And then obviously you have got some traders, some
performers, but they're not on site all the time.
And then Saturday and Sunday we do have some day visitors.
But if we said 300 vehicles a day.
But we also have a no movement policy.
So those 1 ,200 vehicles camping, once they are in,
they are in.
So if they were to leave the site unless there was a medical emergency or something they cannot then return
So you haven't got twelve hundred vehicles on site?
Coming and going or all the time. Thank you
It's the event management plan proposing to have any form of traffic management
Seat 28 - 0:42:58
Yes, so we actually have a traffic management consultant sitting behind you over here and to be entirely fairI haven't advised
officers that he was going to be in attendance today. I wasn't intending to
call him as a witness or anything like that but yes if you have any specific
Seat 8 - 0:43:17
traffic questions I'm sure he'd be delighted to leap up. I was mainly anglingthat for the information that your event management plan was proposing to have
traffic management so that and I'm relieved to hear of the no movement
policy as well. The lanes are quite narrow up that part of the district so I'm aware of that.
So yes, thank you.
Thank you very much.
Seat 1 - 0:43:37
That's all I have.Okay, I had a couple of things.
So how many day visitors do you get?
Because, and what time would you anticipate them leaving?
Because it isn't just the music that generates noise.
It's the people and people driving down
past residential areas.
You know, if there's 200 cars suddenly driving
through Tottenham or through past the estate down that road in Moreton could really generate
Seat 29 - 0:44:11
quite a lot of noise?Well, we have around about 300 on the Saturday and Sunday. Very, very few come on the Friday.
Is that people or cars?
No, that's vehicles. However, they do, because a lot come as a family event, they come for
the daytime activities, you'll find that they trickle in throughout the day, but then they
also trickle out throughout the day.
So you might have someone that comes at 10 o 'clock
in the morning and then might be gone by three o 'clock.
They might come for the dog show or,
you know, it's not a constant thing.
And we often find that by,
by about nine o 'clock at night,
most of the day visitors have actually left.
And is there a time when they have to have left?
11.
Okay, thank you very much.
Can you give me an example of the activities that are going on?
So in terms of the music activities, the show, the sporting activities.
And also the nature of the traders that are there.
I mean, presumably you have some catering vans and things like that.
Yes, so we have around about 15 catering vans.
We're hoping, like I said, to work with Todd and Man of Farm to have one of theirs in as well.
That offers everyone a variety of food, but there's around about 60 trade stores, so a
lot of them will be for upgrading your vehicles.
So you might come and you might buy some new curtains or a bumper or you might need some
parts.
So it's very much aimed at the Volkswagen community, but there might be Volkswagen style
clothing.
And then there are stores that are for everyone, maybe some jewellery and things like that,
because you don't just always want to look at Volkswagen parts.
And then we have to factor in that we're a community event.
So the local community will come
and they might not necessarily just want to look at Volkswagen bits.
But the activities, there are yoga, Pilates, Zumba,
there's massage, Reiki.
So you've got all the wellness activities
that are a big part of the event.
It's about...
People live busy lives.
They come to the event to unwind as well.
It's not just about, like I say, the music and the vehicles.
Then we have scavenger hunts for the children
and entertainers and craft workshops and the dog show.
Then there are community event building,
like we might do sports games
so that it brings local communities
and the Volkswagen groups all can interact.
we have solo meets and greets because it's really important that solo campers can come and meet other people and feel safe.
A lot of the camper chips are one of the group, a lot of solo females, they come and then they use it to
to form a social group that they can then go to other events with. So we find
it's a very much about the social side as well. We have a retro bike show, a
vehicle display. I can literally go on with this
There are so much that you would physically not be able to do it all.
You have to print it off in advance and go,
I'm going to go and do this, this and this, because there is so much to do.
And if people ask for things, we try to put it in.
We ask them, what do you want next year?
They then say, well, we want speed dating, we want this, and we'll put it all in.
It's a community event and it's built by the community.
Thank you very much. That's very comprehensive.
and obviously you're going to have a complete safeguarding cheques in for all
the children's activities that you're doing. Yes, they all wear their own
wristbands with their number and which area they're camping in as well. And the
people who are dealing with the children have been appropriately screened I'm
sure all that's in place. Yeah, yeah. Good, thank you I think I've asked enough
Seat 8 - 0:48:13
questions. Oh sorry, Councillor Evans. It kind of prompted me to thinkyour questions about what kind of music you'd have on the stages. I don't think
you covered that. Could you just outline what kind of activities you have on the
Seat 29 - 0:48:29
stages during the licence? So one of the stages is an acoustic tent, so very muchlike a solo with a guitar and we support as many local musicians as we can with
that tent. So that fits into the wellness area, so has a lower music level because
it's within the Wellness Zone. Then we have the dance tent which is operational more of
an evening. It's the one that runs the shortest hours and that has all the disco DJs. That
marquee actually has doors on it as well so that we can control how many people are coming
in and out of that. And then the main marquee, it's a bit of an eclectic mix. It's bands
and then the Sunday is a tribute festival so we've got things like ABBA, we've got
share Meat Loaf. It's very much those that are in the big hits that people like to sing to.
But yeah, it's very much, it can have soloists on there, bands, trios, and again we try to support
the local artists on that one as well. And if there was a school band we would put them on the
stage. It's about the community. Everything is about the community with our event.
Thank you very much.
Seat 1 - 0:49:42
Seat 8 - 0:49:43
Can I just follow up on that?You mentioned marquees on the music.
Seat 29 - 0:49:49
Are all the stages indoors?Yes, all of them are indoors.
Two of the marquees have the sides with the patio doors that you have to go through to get into those.
And then the main acoustic is like teepee tents, you know, like wigwams.
Two of those put together.
and then and that one stops at about half past eight at night I think I think
the timing so that one drops off quite early and then the main marquee is it's
Seat 8 - 0:50:20
a marquee as well but we don't have an outdoor stage so the speakers for withinSeat 29 - 0:50:26
those speakers for each stage are solely contained within each of the marqueesorry can you say that again we speak at the speakers for each of those stages
Seat 8 - 0:50:33
Seat 29 - 0:50:34
are contained solely within the marquees in which they forget the artist isplaying. Oh very much so because I don't agree with putting them outdoors.
Seat 1 - 0:50:45
Seat 3 - 0:50:52
Okay if you finish with the questions I think we'll now ask. Just to alert you onthe addendum, right, that I'll be looking for an industry standard approach.
Okay, so it's, that's what, it would be an objective test.
Seat 1 - 0:51:18
Thank you very much, April.would you be able to talk us through your concerns and give us a lot of
Seat 22 - 0:51:29
information about noise management? Thank you very much.Okay so as Rebecca alluded there's two streams to our objection in relation to
this event. The first is as you will have read my original objection consortee
comment is to do with the the overall loading of the site. Now we we do not
have in the Cotswold District Council a kind of noise policy that we refer to
environmental health use and refer to the code of practise. It is a recognised
current document hasn't been no updates have been brought out to it and it is
widely used by environmental health officers and it's still delivered in
training to environmental health officers, which I attended in
2024 recently, and it's delivered in those courses as a
document which where applicants, if they demonstrate compliance
with it, it suggests that it's almost like a sort of best
practicable means kind of defence for them, but it doesn't
exempt them from any statute nuisance action.
So it's kind of saying, if you follow this code of practise,
it's likely that complaints will be reduced.
It's not saying that if you follow this code,
you won't get complaints.
It's saying that it's likely that the number
complaints would be reduced.
And ultimately, it's more of a kind of
demonstrating best practise in terms of the event itself.
So in relation to that, the code practise,
as you'll see in my comment, has a table,
table 1 which refers to the number of event days per calendar year per venue.
So the table itself says that for an event venue which we're looking at for
rural venues for one to three days would be a music noise level which does not
exceed or should not exceed 65 DB and for all at all other venue 4 to 12
events which should not exceed background plus 15 DB in relation to
this application but taking the site as a whole because we're looking at that
we're looking at per venue per calendar year so we're looking at the whole site
the issue the reason of our first line of objection is because we have a
granted licence application for Arc Tangent Festival. They are having kind of
three and a bit days of regulated entertainment and they are they are 65 DB
for three days. So they are taking up the full allocation for that site per
year. What the code then says is if an applicant wants to submit an application
for another event on that site which has regulated entertainment. Effectively all
events on that site would need to drop down to the next level. So obviously
Natalie's proposing event obviously now it's proposed for four days of
regulated entertainment in May which takes the overall limit for that site
to seven days over the course of the calendar year for that site. Obviously
it's not limited just to these events,
it's for the whole site for a year.
So all events should then drop down
into the four to 12 a year category.
With this application, the difficulty is,
is obviously there is a current licence in place
which was granted in June for Arc Tangent at the 65 DB.
And for the site as a whole,
it's for Arc Tangent to reduce
when they have already got a licence granted, it is something that is not likely to happen.
So the burden of proof then lies on the second applicant to demonstrate that by their means
of their operation of their event would not cause a nuisance or statutory nuisance or
public nuisance to the residents living in that area. And therefore, that event's music
noise level would have to be sufficiently low as to not cause a nuisance to the neighbours.
So the site loading of the application was our first concern. The second concern was
the submitted information. So on receiving the application, obviously we spoke to the
applicant. We didn't have a noise management plan submitted as part of the application.
Following discussion with the applicant we received a noise management plan.
We reviewed the noise management plan and then we obviously responded because the noise
management plan was insufficient to satisfy us that at first it was a suitable noise management
plan or that it was indeed adequate.
Then obviously we maintained our objection in terms of the application.
We advised the applicant that a suitable qualified acoustic consultant should be appointed to prepare a suitable noise management plan.
Then subsequently we received a second noise management plan from that person which was also inadequate.
But the concern that we have at the present time,
and obviously we take on board what the applicant says
that they've now appointed acoustic consultant,
which is qualified.
The concern that we have is that the information
that we have gained from those two submitted documents
demonstrates that if we take out the first festival
that has been presented, that this festival as it is presented is from what we have seen
unable to demonstrate that they can present a festival that would achieve or would follow
the code of practise for the 65 dB noise level, which would be for one to three events. So
So, obviously, we need to be satisfied.
And the reason why we haven't agreed to the noise management
plan condition prior to this is because we haven't got the
confidence that the presented festival, and actually when I
say haven't got the confidence, we've also from our own kind of
modelling can see that what is demonstrated in those documents
is that the suggested lower noise level could not be complied
with the way in which this festival is being presented as it stands and
therefore significant alterations and amendments need to be achieved in order
to comply with the Code of Practise. If in the event that it's just this festival
on the site and they're proposing a level of or proposing four days of music
noise then obviously then we're looking at obviously negotiations in terms of
how that would effectively come into compliance with us agreeing to those conditions, but
effectively it would fall into the one to three day category. Or if they're planning
a fourth day, it could drop down into the 15 DBa background category. So our principal
concern with the application is obviously there is another festival which is programmed
to run in August of next year, which effectively takes up the full
allocation in terms of POPcode and also this event particularly hasn't satisfied
us from the information that we've received so far that this event can
achieve compliance with POPcode's ad as it stands. If you've got any questions
Seat 1 - 0:59:48
please ask. I'm sure we have got some questions. Is that all you want to tellus at the moment? Okay colleagues do you want to ask April any questions?
Seat 8 - 1:00:00
Just my absolute clarity I think what was the objections and thedifficulty we have here is that in and of itself as a four -day festival with
the evidence that you've seen thus far from the first two noise management
plans this festival in isolation would use up would in fact be long before days
Seat 22 - 1:00:25
rather than the three days the potco would allow us to have so if we tookthis event in isolation and what's been submitted to us to date so far so if
it's a four day event as they're proposing for May it would fall into the
four to 12 category, which was what was presented to us.
In terms of their noise level, which is predicted
and presented and their noise level at their mixing desk,
it's not possible for them to comply with that lower level.
It's not even in terms of how they presented it at near it,
because we're looking at nearest noise sensitive receptors.
So I think there's a couple of people that live quite close
and it's kind of about 350 metres so it's up to the applicant to demonstrate
through obviously liaison with with those residents who they would be
including or discounting as a noise sensitive receptor but from what's being
presented so far it would suggest that even the 65 DB kind of higher limit
isn't going to be present isn't going to be achievable for this application it
made the obviously like we said that the person that wrote the second report
didn't have the relevant level of qualification in order to present that
to us but we can kind of see from what we've what we know about the the noise
level on site we can work out rough you know kind of say well roughly off -site
it would be this and therefore our concern with with the compliance is that
there is that difficulty between the noise levels that are presented and what
Seat 8 - 1:02:07
can be a good what can be agreed going forward okay so basically based on theevidence that's been presented so far in the two noise management plans here the
two you have concerns that they wouldn't be able to meet even the 65 decibels of
course one bait and it's based entirely on the evidence that we've had so far
and that evidence may or may not be robust given the qualifications.
Seat 22 - 1:02:32
Previously in terms of the first noise management plan was a noise managementplan that was submitted apparently in 24 and 25 so it was previous events which
yeah which you know doesn't have any there's no in in the noise management
plan there's no method of monitoring or actually monitoring those events so that
that's why our kind of confidence in what's been submitted in terms of how
they're going to manage and monitor and ensure they're going to comply with you
know those those kind of levels is a concern. I would say as well, marquees
they don't provide that nature thing attenuation for noise so it for us it's
Seat 8 - 1:03:18
classes outdoors. A second question I've got is that the minimum is it M &Mis minimum noise level is it? Music noise level, thank you. Just on the
guideline of should not exceed background noise level by more than 15
decibels, from what you know of the area, roughly how loud might that be?
Seat 22 - 1:03:42
Obviously other applications where there has been done, because it'skind of on the edge of Morton in the marsh, so during the daytime it would be a
bit higher but we're looking at a representative level so you could say
35 40 in the evening what the applicant has to demonstrate to us is that they've
carried out a sufficient background monitoring of the area at representative
time so that's in the evening so I think it's the code of practise explains how
to do it it's like the last four hours of your event so it covers that quieter
night time period. And obviously then whatever accurate background noise level is obtained
from that monitoring, because it's taken at the nearest, or at the agreed nearest noise
sensitive premises, it's then 15 dB on top of that. But obviously that's, in terms of
The top code and the site specific,
it's not designed to be a cumulative table.
So it's, you have one to three events at this level
or four to 12 at this level.
In this case, our tangent are one to three at the top.
Yeah, so this event has to demonstrate
that it's going to be significantly
kind of non impactful for residents.
and it is a kind of a limitation for this event that there is currently an
event that's got a licence already and obviously that's where that's where our
kind of two streams of concern remain. Sorry just just to pick up on it for me
Seat 8 - 1:05:28
and you said that it work cumulative so you couldn't have one to three at 65 andthen another four to twelve. Right, fine. It's one or the other.
Seat 22 - 1:05:39
Yeah, the guidance says it might be that, you know, if in the event that it is decidedthat another event could go ahead, then obviously then you might say, well, you could go with
the lower level because you'll be looking at things like, you know, the time between
the events, but we very much look at the, like when we're agreeing if we're going
outside of the code of practise, we're looking at how the events have been run
in the past. A lot of our events, you know, ran for quite a long time. If they can
demonstrate compliance, they would, you know, and it's, they're managing their
event well, we give, we can, you know, we have the remit to give a little bit of
leeway and say, you know, oh well yes, okay, you could do this. Where, when we get to a
where it's a new application and it you know we'd want to be satisfied that the
applicant can achieve you know that you know in compliance in life with the POP
code or you demonstrate that they can work in line with that but we're not
saying it's kind of an absolute no you can't do something else it's where we're
satisfied that that the person can run that event sufficiently well and it's
not affecting the residents and and another key concern with this
application is that currently that site hasn't been tested for this sort of
these sorts of events obviously if our tangent is on that site it's a heavy
metal festival it's a big festival as well so it's we don't know how that
events gonna go or how another events because we you know it's if they're both
effectively new to that site so for the residents you know it's kind of bringing
Seat 8 - 1:07:21
two events where a site hasn't been used for that sort of purpose before. So thedemonstration of whether an event is managed is particularly, you would be
looking at that particular site rather than any proposed, the actuality of the
Seat 22 - 1:07:37
previous event of that site as opposed to an event management plan or... That holdsother events we've looked at, you know, because the actual landowner has a
licence for a sale of alcohols they like, they have the Christmas fair, it's not
predominantly a music event, they have other events, temporary event notices get
put onto that, so it's this the allocation is for the site as a whole, so if
another person wants to come along and present an application, we look at it as
a whole site event, not just looking at each event in isolation where they
comply you know oh well I can comply with pop code for this it's it's the
Seat 8 - 1:08:20
site in as it stands over the course of a year so just just to labour that pointthat our evidence of this site is not comparable is not so previous events at
this site are not sufficiently comparable for this kind of event that's
Seat 22 - 1:08:37
applied for here? What's previously been on that site there's been some temporaryevent notices for smaller events. Obviously Art Tangent three -day music
festival is the first application that we got for this site in terms of a big
festival and then obviously this application is subsequently the next.
Obviously we welcome the fact that the applicant has taken the August
event away because other considerations would be kind of when
Seat 8 - 1:09:11
you're having two big events in one month. Thank you.Seat 1 - 1:09:13
Have you got any questions? No. Okay, so I've got a couple of questions. So there's 65decibels, that's the nearest noise receptor, is it the nearest? The nearest
agreed noise sensitive receptor. So you go with the nearest noise sensitive
receptor. Which is the residential. Yeah residential premises. If in the event that the
you know the person that lived there said oh no you know if it's a if it's an
owner -occupied property and they say oh I'm really happy for this event to go
ahead I'm happy to discount myself as a noise sensitive receptor the applicant
could provide evidence of that and then they can say we're discounting this
person as a noise -sensitive receptor we'll go to the next one because there
are people that live quite close. It's difficult when you have a rental
property situation because if someone says well I'm happy to be discounted as
a noise -sensitive receptor and they move out and somebody else moves in and then they
make a complaint of nuisance it's obviously for us to assess
whether it's a statutory nuisance so you know it can get a little bit tricky
where you've got people that aren't living permanently in a place.
But also other noise sensitive receptors such as the fire service, college and
people like that, they're not that close but they're relatively close.
Okay, so can you just tell me, I know that you can have live and amplified music
at certain hours without requiring a licence, is that correct?
Seat 22 - 1:10:51
So, yeah, so but only in situations where, so it comes under the live music app where,so like if you've already got a premises licence, such as a pub for example, and they want to
put on a live band in the garden, they can have that music for up to, what is it, 499,
499 people in their current licence premise without having to have a separate licence
for regulated entertainment.
This event is obviously a premises licence to put on regulated entertainment.
Seat 1 - 1:11:21
Seat 22 - 1:11:28
So if the farm for example had their own premises licence it would be okay?In that situation obviously the land itself there's a premises licence for sale of
alcohol because the land owner has a, you know, puts on the Christmas fairs and
if there are these if there are two like two events or one event on the site if
we receive other applications for other events we're assessing it on the basis
of whether that the loading of the entire site so we need to look at those
subsequent applications to determine whether because you're adding multiple
Seat 1 - 1:12:01
events to a site. So the fact that the there is a licence to sell alcohol onthe site doesn't then give authority for this the music between A to Clubman?
They're not regulated for entertainment on their own licence.
So they put in temporary event notices if they wanted to do certain events, smaller kind of events for the site.
Seat 22 - 1:12:24
But these two applications are separate to obviously Art Tangent and to the applicant themselves.Seat 28 - 1:12:30
If it helps just by way of background, the landowner with their premises licence,If it's for sale of alcohol only what April saying is they could have regulated and what we would consider regulated entertainment
So live or recorded music within their licenced area between the hours of 8 o 'clock in the morning at 11 o 'clock at night
But only if it was for an audience of up to four nine nine
So there is that deregulation
Seat 22 - 1:12:58
Between those hours, but for a smaller audiences of four. Yeah for smaller eventThey would also if they're putting on regulated entertainment fall under the provisions of pop go where?
you're looking at the multiple events so you go into those more event days over the course of a year.
Seat 1 - 1:13:12
Seat 22 - 1:13:18
Okay, so if there was no music to be had at this festival there wouldn't be a problem, is that right?So obviously if the applicant says well I'm going to not have any amplified music, I'm going to have
acoustic people or sets or change the way in which they deliver the festival and they're not,
site you can't hear it then there's you know from a noise perspective there's no
concern from us in terms of that it's the applicant to demonstrate that the
level is sufficiently low that it isn't causing a nuisance or a public nuisance
Seat 1 - 1:13:52
Seat 22 - 1:13:53
to nearest noise sensitive residents. This is you know like what likeeverybody said it's guidance but it's it's established guidance that says if
Seat 1 - 1:14:05
you follow this complaints are less likely. So what does that you're sayingthat they could have so no you're saying that they couldn't be up to 50 over 50
Seat 22 - 1:14:17
the 15 decibel thing that's out of the window because of the other festival isSeat 1 - 1:14:22
that right? Yeah so effectively for the site yes. So for this to be allowed theySeat 22 - 1:14:28
would have to be no sort of noise escape at all from the site? I mean that'ssomething that it would have to be decided in terms of,
effectively, yes, the load for the site is taken
with the one to three, so there isn't any room
on this site to go, well, you can have more events
because everybody would have to go down to the lower level.
But if you were minded to grant the level,
you would look at a suitably low level,
which might be, you know,
well, we would look at what suitably low level
we would agree to in terms of the,
if the condition was imposed to provide a noise management plan,
we would then have to agree at a suitably low level
where we would feel that if that level of compliance was achieved,
it wouldn't cause a statutory nuisance or public nuisance to the residents.
Seat 1 - 1:15:16
Okay, and this is a code of practise.It's not a sort of legal requirement.
Seat 22 - 1:15:26
It's kind of official title is the Code of Practise on Environmental Noise Control atConcerts, but it's widely, you know, obviously outdoor music concerts or events.
It is established in case law and it wasn't actually, was the word I forgot in my head
now, it wasn't actually formally withdrawn by the Charter Institute of Environmental
Health, what they said was they were going to review it and they currently are reviewing
it and it is subject to being under a process of review but no subsequent updated document
has been published.
So it's still widely used by environmental health professionals as a means to demonstrate
that if it's followed it's less likely to cause, I mean it doesn't
exempt a person from any action from us if such a situation occurred but
it's almost like a defence for the applicant to say well I'm
within this guidance.
Seat 1 - 1:16:42
You saw the suggestion put forward by the applicant about having the condition thatyou would have to approve an acoustic noise management plan no later than two months before
the start of the event. Do you want to say what you think about that? I think you've
Seat 22 - 1:17:06
actually said you don't think they can comply with what's required? Yes obviously ourconcern with the application so far is that what has been provided demonstrates
that you know that the noise level would would at noise sensitive not comply with
the with the higher level. That's not to say that they couldn't do a lot you know
work to to with a qualified acoustic consultant to get get compliance with
that level. Mike can, I mean obviously it is a risk for the applicant because it's
you know it's saying two months before the event we have to we have to say yes
to that noise management plan in order for their event to go ahead. I mean
obviously we've had discussions with Rebecca and their intention is not to
submit us a noise management plan you know two months before the event anyway.
They want to try and do it as quickly as they can because they don't want to be
a position where you know we're not agreeing that noise management plan.
Obviously it's a recognised and well used condition. The obviously the the issue is
if you are minded to grant the event obviously there's the there's the
benefit for the applicant in the fact that if that if they were the only event
on the site then they would have they could you know they if they could change
their event or if there are two events then they have to account for that so it
does give an element of flexibility in terms of how the events run on the side
but obviously it's with our agreement that that occurs and I think we would
say as a result of this if that's something that you're going to go with
that we would set out kind of key elements that are needed to be addressed
by the applicant that we would we would be looking at for approval if that was
Seat 1 - 1:18:52
be put in place. So you're not against the idea of having this modification? Ithink you sort of said that you didn't think they would be able to come up with
Seat 22 - 1:19:02
it but you're not saying it's impossible? No because they couldchange the nature of the event or they could do different things.
There's a lot of it, I mean if you've got a qualified acoustic consultant they can
do lots of reorientation stages, they can change it. My concern is the event as it's
proposed as it stands would be that the compliance with what is being suggested
would be difficult but that's not to say that they could come up with some you
Seat 1 - 1:19:34
Seat 22 - 1:19:35
know way in which they could achieve that lower level. There's also a caveatto that as well for the applicant because obviously it does involve you
know it is it is likely to involve the significant change to their event to in
to get to that level because if you're looking at a low level in 15 DB above
background say or not exceeding that level then the on -site experience for
people would be very different to what they've previously held as that event in
order to get that off -site low level as it stands if there are in excess of four
Seat 1 - 1:20:15
events, for event days. Thank you very much. Do you have any furtherquestions? Is there anyone else who wants to make a representation? Otherwise, do
any of you want to say anything? You can now ask
Seat 28 - 1:20:38
questions, yeah, you can ask questions of the officers. You'veto ask the question you come. You've said that Arc Tangent are taking three days
and that they're three days but in their application they actually have music on
four and it is publicly advertised that the Wednesday night has music so that
goes across four days so in theory what you were saying should they not then be
Seat 22 - 1:21:02
operating at the 15 decibel above MNL? With Arc Tangent's application we had a lotnoise management plan with the application and we had lengthy
discussions with the applicant. The applicant and the management company
that run our tangent, they already run 2000 Trees which is in Cotswold
District Council and they were looking to move their second event which they
run in another council into Cotswold District Council. They approached us
because they were looking for a full four -day 65 DB event to run
at this site. We said no, we wouldn't accept a four day event, we would accept three days at 65
initially. So then there was a bit of to and from between us and the acoustic consultants
and the applicant to achieve. So on the fourth day they've got a much, they've got a lower noise
level but they've also got a reduced day. So they're doing a kind of VIP day so that they
finish earlier they've got I think they go to a what's it called
silent disco as part of that application as well that in relation to that event
there as a as a company that runs events in our area they're well established
you found entries have run for a long time our concern was obviously about the
the this new site and the event site so in that we've said you can have three
days at 65 but if in the future it's demonstrated that you can manage this
event and it doesn't cause an issue we might go to a year we could say well you
could potentially have a fourth day which is not uncommon they run I think
they already run two thousand trees anyway as a four day event but we have
confidence in that applicant that the noise management plan that was submitted
with their application demonstrated that they could comply with the pop code in terms of
how they were going to present their event, their low frequency assessment, their monitoring
and planning of the event itself.
And also the monitoring inside of it is really important because it's not just about saying
what we can comply with this level, it's how the applicant demonstrates to us that they
are going to manage that off -site and who they're going to have doing it and
how they're going to monitor it. We go out and do monitoring ourselves but it's
for the applicant to demonstrate compliance with the licencing conditions
and all of that information was provided up front as part of that application so
we were satisfied that we were happy with that application as it's granted.
Thank you very much.
Seat 28 - 1:24:00
Just address some issues in summing up if I might, Chair.Can I just ask how long we have? Is there a time limit for the summing up?
It just says briefly.
If I could have five minutes for that, then I have no questions.
Five minutes would be fine.
Super.
Seat 1 - 1:24:19
It just says briefly.I am going to suggest five minutes.
You don't want to ask any further questions.
Let's just see.
Did you want to ask the applicant anything?
Seat 22 - 1:24:43
Seat 1 - 1:24:46
April. No, I don't think so. Great. So we're now down to point 13. The chairmanascertains that all parties are satisfied they've said all they wish to
say, apart from you, Rebecca, that you're going to sum up. Yeah, would you like to
Seat 28 - 1:25:11
give us a brief summary five minutes. Sure thank you chair. So there are thereare two issues here with regards to this application but both are about how noise
carries exactly as I think you identified chair there's no problem here
with the sale of alcohol at this event there's no problem with the ancillary
activities that are taking place I don't think anybody is concerned about the
questions but I don't think anybody's concerned about the traffic for example
We are talking about music noise and how it carries.
So that is the sole basis from which you're going to make this decision.
There's been a lot of talk about the POP code.
I'm going to repeat what I said, that it is guidance.
It is not, as you've said, statutory.
It is outdated.
It has been withdrawn, albeit, as April says, it is referenced
that it is still the most up -to -date because it hasn't been replaced.
It is entirely evident that events can operate out with that policy, including events that
have been mentioned within this district.
So it is not black and white.
It also, as I've said, is not referenced in your policy.
Your policy talks about large scale outdoor events and references the purple guide and
it makes no reference to the POP code.
It is widely used, I'm not arguing with April that it isn't widely used, but it's also widely
disregarded in various locations, hundreds of locations up and down the country, because
it was put together at a time when the way we live, the way events are carried out, the
way acoustics work were different.
There's also nothing in the Code itself, and just to deal with one of the questions that
you asked, there is nothing in the Code which says that those one to three event days cannot
be cumulative with the four to, one to three with the additional four to 12.
It doesn't say that anywhere in the Code.
There are various other factors to be considered,
and April said in her submissions,
and I wrote it at the time,
if we're going to go outside of the Code of Practise,
other things are to be considered,
time between events, et cetera, et cetera.
So it can be done.
It can be done, and it is done.
It was done with the granting of our tangents licence
with a bit of horse trading about when this will happen
and what levels will be here and there, et cetera, et cetera.
So the aim of the Licencing Act
is not to achieve compliance with the code.
It's to avoid public nuisance.
There's been discussion about the closest resident
and how we assess them in terms of the nearest
noise -sensitive receptor.
There is an estate resident here who is the closest,
and he has confirmed to the landlord that he's
perfectly happy for this application to be granted.
That's something I would have touched on in submissions.
I know I didn't, but hopefully you'll give me
a bit of leeway on that, given that I didn't get
to all of it.
So the issue we have is our noise management plan,
and what that will say and what that will achieve.
And frankly and respectfully, I completely understand
that we're not in an ideal position
in not being able to produce that plan
and to produce more specifics today.
But I don't understand what the issue is
with this condition that we've offered.
April said, and again, I wrote it down,
that's not to say that they couldn't do,
they, Natalie, we, couldn't do a lot of work
to get to compliance.
I think that's a really vital statement in what April said.
She also said, there's a lot of things that we might be able to
do with the help of an acoustic consultant.
And that is exactly our point.
We simply want to be given the opportunity to produce something
that will satisfy environmental health that this event can
proceed without causing a nuisance.
It has been achieved at other locations.
Natalie has done it.
The levels have been as required by the POP code or as suggested
by the POP code.
And monitoring has been done previously by environmental
health officers who have always been happy.
April is saying she doesn't have the information, the detail that she needs to sign this off now, or the confidence that it can be achieved.
But candidly, that's fine. If she doesn't think it can be achieved, give Natalie the opportunity to prove her wrong.
Because there isn't a risk here, councillors. The condition that we've offered provides an absolute veto to your Environmental Health team.
As I've said, that's a risk for us, but it's one that Natalie is happy to take because she wants to work in partnership.
April has said it might be that a new acoustic consultant can present something to them that
shows compliance.
So I would submit by adding this condition to the licenced counsellors, there's no risk
here to manage at all.
If our acoustic consultant can't satisfy the concerns that April has expressed to you today,
there won't be an event.
That's year on year as well.
The way that I phrased this is that no event will be permitted to proceed without a noise
management plan coming at least two months before.
So it's not let's produce a noise management plan this year and on we go for the rest of the rest of forever
This is a noise management plan each year that would satisfy environmental health concerns
And this is a moving feast as we've said
It's not guaranteed that our tangent is going to take place on this location
And that would mean that the noise management plan might look different and what April needs us to achieve might look different
So in order to achieve can you can you sum up very quickly?
In order to achieve compliance with the licencing objectives,
you don't need to refuse this application.
You simply need to add this condition.
I would suggest that that would be in accordance with the
National Licencing Policy Framework, which came into force last year,
which requires a licencing system that is flexible and responsive,
a tool for enabling innovation and investment, not just managing risk.
Licencing should support a diverse range of venues and experiences
that reflect the UK's rich hospitality and leisure offer.
The framework recognises a need for a light touch and that licencing should be permissive
by design.
Natalie wants to work with your Environmental Health team as regulator to prove that this
event can proceed in the way it has done in other locations and uphold the licencing objectives
in doing so.
If I was simply asking you to grant this licence on Natalie's word today, I have no doubt
that your decision would be different.
But my respectful submission is that by adding this condition you can be guaranteed that one way or another
the licencing objectives will be upheld and I would therefore respectfully suggest that that is the proportionate decision today councillors. Thank you very much.
Okay, has everybody said all they want to say?
Okay in that case
it's now up to us as a committee to debate the application.
Should we go next door into the committee room or should we ask everyone to?
So we'll go away. If you'd like to go and get yourself a cup of tea or something,
we'll come back and tell you about 20 minutes or so.
8 Decision
Seat 1 - 1:31:54
Thank you. We're good to go? Thank you very much for your patience. We've had ourdebate with input from our legal officers, so thank you very much for that.
So, first of all, I just wanted to be clear over the changes which the applicant has suggested
to the event.
So, she's suggesting now one event per year rather than two.
This will be in May, June, probably normally on the late May bank holiday.
The entertainment provision will be from Thursday to Sunday only, not Monday.
And there will be an addition of alcohol sales on Wednesday evening, which would be for the
crew and the traders.
So in arriving at their decision,
the subcommittee has taken into account
requirements to promote the four licencing objectives.
The subcommittee has taken into account
relevant representations from the residents and the public,
including written representations, relevant authorities,
and responses from the applicant
and the council's environmental team.
Thank you very much to you all.
In addition, the subcommittee has had regard
to the statutory guidance under section 182 of the Licencing Act 2003 and the
authorities statement of the licencing policy. Taking all these things
into account, the subcommittee has decided to grant the application subject
to conditions which I'm going to outline now. The following conditions, the
mandatory conditions of the Licencing Act 2003, the proposed conditions
suggested by the police which has been accepted by the applicant. Then in
addition we would also like to accept the suggested amendment given by the applicant and her agent.
I'm going to read it out loud. We've changed the wording slightly.
Okay? So, location and event specific acoustic assessment
and noise management plan shall be submitted
to Cotswold District Council Environmental Health no later,
and preferably quite a lot earlier,
than two months before the start of each
and every event taking place under this licence.
So, every time you have one,
the noise management plan has to be accepted.
So, these documents must be approved in writing
by the environmental health team prior to the event being permitted to proceed.
So the environmental health team potentially have a veto if they're not
happy with your noise management plan. You understand that, don't you? Once
approved, the agreed noise management plan shall be fully complied with during
the course of the event. Thank you very much. Okay, it says that you have rights
of appeal but presumably you're not going to want to appeal. Appeal must be
made to the Magistrates Court if you're not happy with the conditions.
For example, you can make an appeal to the Magistrates Court within 21 days of
notification of the authorities' decisions.
So also there are procedures, you need to know this, contained within the Licencing Act 2003
relating to reviews of the premises licence.
And this provision allows nearby residents or businesses or responsible authorities to apply for
a review of the premises licence if there are any problems.
with any of the statutory licencing policy,
the licencing objectives,
if we feel any of those are not being complied with,
so public safety, crime and disorder,
public nuisance and the protection of children from harm,
if any people want to challenge the licence
on the basis that any of those things are happening,
they're entitled to do so.
So you understand all that,
but granted the licence.
Seat 1 - 1:35:50
With those conditions, it's quite a stringent conditionand I'm just hoping that you'll be able to come
to an agreement over it.
Seat 9 - 1:35:57
Chair, if I may, may I ask you to briefly summariseyour reasons for the grant?
Just so that it's on the webcast.
Seat 1 - 1:36:06
Sorry, sorry, I should summarise my reasons.Okay, so we have said that we support the application.
There are no concerns from most of the relevant authorities
which includes highways who are satisfied with the traffic management plan, for example.
So the main concerns arise from the environmental team over noise management, and that's why
we've added the extra condition which I have just outlined.
Okay.
Webcast Finished - 1:36:29
Thank you very much.- LicensingProcedures (Licensing Act 2003 Matters), opens in new tab
- Report - Dubs in the Middle, opens in new tab
- Annex A - Copy of Application, opens in new tab
- Annex B - Agreed Conditions, opens in new tab
- Annex C - Plan of Site and Location, opens in new tab
- Annex D - Representations (Support and Objections), opens in new tab
- Representations (Objections), opens in new tab